Call to Assize: Faeran Stonewall

[Zakiyya Ajam]

No further questions

[Altus Whyte]

Defendant, you may now question the witness or state that you do not have any questions.

Do so within 24 hours.

[Faeran Stonewall]

1.) Do you have any proof that I was in the Garrison's channel on the day of the "murder"?

2.) Since you were supposedly noticing all the channels I was in, which channel was I in when I killed Zakkiya?

3.) Did you know RPK was at war with 3 different guilds on the day of the "murder"?

4.) Did you know Zakkiya was unmarked, and not PROPERLY on the forums on the day of the "murder"?

5.) You state that you saw this whole thing happen is that correct? You stated that I said "run" to him AFTER he got killed, that I was "taunting" him right? If that's the case, how is it taunting when Zakkiya's image shows the same conversation BEFORE his death (notice how the text above it says, "Gotharian says: Gotharian eat this"?

http://imgur.com/2IEtQ9N - Zakkiya's Image

http://imgur.com/zcazIIN - Camarro's Image

6.) Neither of us (Zakkiya or Faeran) stated that I said "run" AFTER Zakkiya's death. Therefore, I would like you to please explain how that chat log ended up on your screen without noticing what was happening.

7.) Images show that you saw what was going on. Why didn't you tell me Zakkiya was a serf while I was waiting for his response?

[Altus Whyte]

Witness, proceed and submit answers to the questions within 24 hours.

Objections are to be made within 24 hours.

[Zakiyya Ajam]

1. Do you have any proof that I was in the Garrison's channel on the day of the "murder"?

Objection your Honor: Mr. Valkran is in the court as an eye witness and therefore direct evidence to the event.

1. Since you were supposedly noticing all the channels I was in, which channel was I in when I killed Zakkiya?

   1. No objections.

2. Did you know RPK was at war with 3 different guilds on the day of the "murder"?

   1. Objection your Honor: Irrelevant question. This has nothing to do with Mr. Valkran's statement or the events of that day.

1. Did you know Zakkiya was unmarked, and not PROPERLY on the forums on the day of the "murder"?

   1. Objection your Honor: Irrelevant question, misleading, and asked and answered. Court has evidence that Zakkiya was registered on the forums during the time of the event in question.

2. You state that you saw this whole thing happen is that correct? You stated that I said "run" to him AFTER he got killed, that I was "taunting" him right? If that's the case, how is it taunting when Zakkiya's image shows the same conversation BEFORE his death (notice how the text above it says, "Gotharian says: Gotharian eat this"?
   
   http://imgur.com/2IEtQ9N - Zakkiya's Image
   
   http://imgur.com/zcazIIN - Camarro's Image

   1. Objection your Honor: Compound question.

3. Neither of us (Zakkiya or Faeran) stated that I said "run" AFTER Zakkiya's death. Therefore, I would like you to please explain how that chat log ended up on your screen without noticing what was happening.

   1. Objection: Calls for speculation .

1. Images show that you saw what was going on. Why didn't you tell me Zakkiya was a serf while I was waiting for his response?

   1. Objection your Honor: Vague question. “His response” isn't a set time and could refer to one of many times both prior to and after the events in question.

[Camarro Valkran]

1.) Do you have any proof that I was in the Garrison's channel on the day of the "murder"?

I was concerned that a breach of security had occurred so at 08:12 on 9 Jan 2104 I posted this question in the forum: "Is it OK to have members of RPK

in the Garrison TS, especially while we are at war? I am simply asking because I don't know the Duchy rules, but I'll admit I was surprised." The post

included this image:

2.) Since you were supposedly noticing all the channels I was in, which channel was I in when I killed Zakkiya?

I do not recall.

4.) Did you know Zakkiya was unmarked, and not PROPERLY on the forums on the day of the "murder"?

As regards her tag, she was untagged as per the standing WSX wartime instructions, viz. non-combatants should remove tags to avoid being blue scouted.

As regards her status on the forums on the day in question I have no idea.



3, 5, 6, 7 Removed - Objection sustained.

[Altus Whyte]

#1 overruled. He can still be asked about evidence in addition to his witnessing.

#3 sustained.

#4 overruled.

#5 sustained.

#6 sustained.

#7 sustained.


Defendant, clarify or reword what you're asking in question 6. You can not ask for speculation. Define exactly when "while I was waiting for his response" is in question 7. Do so within 24 hours


Witness, answer the following three questions meanwhile:

You state that you saw this whole thing happen is that correct?

You stated that I said "run" to him AFTER he got killed, that I was "taunting" him right?

If that's the case, how is it taunting when Zakkiya's image shows the same conversation BEFORE his death (notice how the text above it says, "Gotharian says: Gotharian eat this"?

http://imgur.com/2IEtQ9N - Zakkiya's Image

http://imgur.com/zcazIIN - Camarro's Image

[Camarro Valkran]

You state that you saw this whole thing happen is that correct?

To the best of my knowledge I have not stated that I saw "the whole thing." I have described in my statement to the court what I saw.

You stated that I said "run" to him AFTER he got killed, that I was "taunting" him right?

If that's the case, how is it taunting when Zakkiya's image shows the same conversation BEFORE his death (notice how the text above it says, "Gotharian says: Gotharian eat this"?

http://imgur.com/2IEtQ9N - Zakkiya's Image

http://imgur.com/zcazIIN - Camarro's Image

My evidence stated the sequence of events as I believed it to be at the time. Given the overall context and the comments "run" and "hehehe" I consider my description of taunting to be justified.

[Faeran Stonewall]

6.) Mr.Valkran, were you there during the actual killing of Zakkiya? If not, why does the chat log clearly show that you were?

7.) Images show that you saw what was going on. Why didn't you tell me Zakkiya was a serf in between when I tried communicating with him to the time of the killing?

[Altus Whyte]

Witness, proceed and answer the last questions within 24 hours.